Fight Cruelty

Anatomy of an Animal Crime Scene

After the ASPCA helps law enforcement save animals from dire conditions, we’re concerned with ensuring no other animals face the same fate. One way we do that is by helping investigate animal crime scenes.

Enter the ASPCA’s groundbreaking veterinary forensic sciences program. This relatively new field uses forensic sciences—just like those used in human CSI—to locate, record and preserve physical evidence in an animal-related investigation.

Without physical evidence—including bones, animals, animal remains and even financial records—we couldn’t show the link between the victims, suspects, objects and crime scene, so vet forensics is a critical tool in the fight against animal cruelty.

Every crime scene is different, but, Dr. Jason Byrd explains, ASPCA forensic scientists use the following steps to gather evidence.

Assessment


When our Forensic Sciences team arrives at a crime scene, they assess the situation. They examine what dangers might be present, how to best collect the evidence, and whether they need extra specialists or equipment.

Observation


Next, the team does a walk-through of the crime scene to provide initial documentation. A scene photographer and scribe (writer) comb the property, carefully and thoroughly documenting the scene’s conditions when investigators arrive.

The lead investigator and evidence collection team follow. They assess how to best collect the physical evidence on scene, and to make note of what areas might be at risk for contamination or destruction during investigation—those should be processed first. All the while, the team takes copious notes.

Documentation


This could be the most important phase of all. There are four major forms of crime scene documentation: notes, photography, videography, and sketches, and they all must be done throughout the investigation.

The team takes notes throughout the entire investigation. They include all observations of the scene, actions taken, techniques used, description of evidence located, and any other relevant information. 

Photographs are the most crucial aspect of scene documentation because they capture an accurate representation of the scene and any evidence.  The team takes photos at three levels (overall, midrange, and close-up) to document not only the initial condition of the scene but also to document any changes made during the investigation.  We can never take too many photographs.

As a supplement to photography, we use videography to show the scene in real time and to demonstrate the spatial relationship of objects within the scene. 

Sketches, both rough and final, are be made of the scene to show the relationship of key items of evidence in the scene to each other and to the surroundings. They include measurements and descriptions of the items depicted on the sketches. 

Search


The team has to conduct a systematic search of each crime scene to ensure they catch all the evidence. Based on the size of the scene and the number of people involved, the team chooses a method, like a grid search or spiral search.

Collection and Packaging


The purpose of proper evidence collection and packaging is to avoid contamination, damage, or loss of evidence.  The principles of this phase largely rely on common sense; always wear gloves, never re-use packaging material, package items separately, and use rigid containers for breakable items. 

The specific methods used will depend on the type of evidence being collected.  For example, trace evidence should be collected with tweezers or tape and packaged in a small envelope, whereas biological evidence that might be wet should be allowed to air dry before being packaged in paper and kept refrigerated. 

Once the evidence has been collected and placed into its proper packaging, the container must be sealed, labeled, and signed to prevent tampering with the evidence.  As soon as an item of evidence is collected, it should be entered onto both the evidence log and the chain of custody form, which will eventually show a judge that the evidence being admitted in court is the same as the evidence that was collected on scene.

Analysis


This phase uses the scientific method to form hypotheses, carry out experiments to test the hypotheses, and draw conclusions from the evidence collection. 

The lab testing can involve blood, physical items with blood on them, deceased animals, DNA, bone, tissues and many other things. Blood testing for DNA (to determine individual source, or species), bones (trauma analysis and morrow fat testing), deceased animals for necropsy, insect evidence and plant evidence.

DNA testing and trauma analysis can take days to weeks depending on the case. Once the team has its findings, it reports them to the ASPCA Field Investigator, who then provides the reports to law enforcement and prosecutors for case proceedings such as depositions, pre-trial hearings and trial.